Grade 5 vs Grade 23 Titanium (Ti-6Al-4V vs ELI)
Both are Ti-6Al-4V. Grade 23 is the same alloy with “extra low interstitial” control — tighter oxygen, nitrogen and iron ceilings. You give up roughly 35 MPa of nominal tensile to buy fracture toughness and predictable behaviour in thin sections and cold service. This page is when that trade pays, and when it does not.
Head to Head (published ASTM minima)
| Property | Grade 5 (R56400) | Grade 23 ELI (R56401) |
|---|---|---|
| Alloy | Ti-6Al-4V | Ti-6Al-4V, low-interstitial |
| Tensile min | 895 MPa | 860 MPa |
| Yield min | 828 MPa | 785 MPa |
| Oxygen max | 0.20 % | 0.13 % |
| Iron max | 0.30 % | 0.25 % |
| Driving property | maximum strength | toughness / fatigue reliability |
| Specs you will see | ASTM B348/B265, AMS 4928 | ASTM F136, ISO 5832-3, cryo vessels |
What ELI Control Actually Buys You
Oxygen and iron are the elements that harden titanium and quietly embrittle it. Holding them down costs the mill vacuum time and stricter chemistry rejection, and it is what makes ELI the default where parts are thin-walled, cold-formed, cryogenic, repeatedly fatigued, or inside a body. Not stronger — tougher at a slightly lower strength band.
Specify Grade 23 When…
- The drawing or spec names ASTM F136 / ISO 5832-3 (implant-grade bar, plate, wire) — buy ELI, full stop.
- Thin-section fatigue drives the design: spring contacts, medical screws, small-diameter tube that will be cycled.
- Cryogenic or sub-zero service, where Gr5 loses toughness margin and ELI keeps ductility.
- You are cold-forming or deep-drawing the alloy — the extra elongation headroom is real.
Grade 5 Is the Right Call When…
- Static strength rules and the section is forgiving: shafts, bolt stock, structural fittings, motorsport parts.
- Nothing in the spec says ELI: paying the ELI premium for a bracket nobody cycles is a budget error, not a safety margin.
- Marine hardware in Gr5 — corrosion is the same oxide film either way.
Fabrication Notes
Machining behaviour is close enough that shops treat them as one family. Welding discipline is identical — ELI does not forgive contamination, it just fails more gracefully afterwards. If a joint is weld-critical, fix the gas shielding, do not upgrade the sheet number.
Price Logic (qualitative)
ELI carries a premium from vacuum processing and tighter chemistry rejection at the mill. On kg-for-kg it is the more expensive way to buy slightly less strength; per part it can be cheaper when toughness lets you thin a wall or skip a forging step. Send us both callouts on one drawing and we will price the trade honestly.
Full Gr5 pageFull Gr23 pageGrade cross-reference chartQuote both grades